One Scoop
One huge scoop of your selected flavor of ice cream in a cone or a cup.
US$3.50
Two Scoops
Two gigantic scoops of your selected flavor of ice cream.
US$5.00
Ninety Niner Diner offers a delightful mix of casual comfort food that brings warmth to the belly. Ice cream lovers can indulge in either one or two scoops for an average price of $4.25. Their pizza is a great deal too, priced at $15 for a whole pie or by the slice, catering to both those who dine in and those on the go.
The menu also features the highly praised brisket sandwich and brisket tacos, sure to please anyone with a taste for BBQ. Don't miss the BBQ sandwiches, a staple that showcases the smoky and rich flavors. With an average price of $9.62 across all dishes, it's a wallet-friendly option for locals and visitors alike.












Ninety Niner Diner features a cozy and inviting interior that feels like a home away from home. The decor reflects a classic diner vibe, complete with booths and a friendly atmosphere. Soft lighting enhances the ambiance, making it an ideal spot for family gatherings or a quick break on the journey through Sutton-Alpine.
The aroma of freshly cooked food greets you as you walk in. Vibrant conversations fill the air, highlighting the community aspect of this diner. It’s not just a meal; it’s an experience, often coupled with ice cream treats that evoke nostalgia for many.

The food at Ninety Niner Diner stands out for its hearty, comforting appeal. Known for its brisket sandwiches, this diner delivers tender brisket paired with soft bread. The brisket tacos provide a tasty twist, wrapping up that same savory goodness in a hand-held format perfect for a quick bite.
Ice cream fans rave about the variety, making it an essential stop. Simple pleasures like the pepperoni pizza create a welcoming atmosphere often filled with laughter and conversation. Diners can savor the familiar tastes of American comfort food, including barbeque classics, which have become local favorites.

Ninety Niner Diner stands committed to serving high-quality, delicious food that reflects the community’s spirit. The diner specializes in hearty meals that fill both the stomach and the heart, often bringing together flavors that resonate with both locals and visitors. The vision is simple: create a space where everyone feels at home, enjoys great food, and builds connections. By prioritizing the use of local ingredients whenever possible, the diner strives to be a key player in promoting regional flavors. This commitment to quality and community sets Ninety Niner Diner apart in Sutton-Alpine, making it more than just a place to eat but a beloved local institution.